jk's Tarot Deck Buyer's
Guide Ratings

SYMBOL
RATING
EXPLANATION

Dogma
Rating

1 cross—YAM's delight
2 crosses—TV Guide
3 crosses—Catholicism
4 crosses—E=MC2

The deck's ideas and ideology. Generally, this rating will take into account the textual content of some accompanying book (preferably written by the deck's designer), but that's not always the case. The symbol is the triple-cross/Ankh of Ptah, which Court de Gébelin interpreted as the original papal, or Hierophant's cross, in his Egyptian-Tarotic dogma.

Cartomantic
Rating

1 Merc—Miss Cleo
2 Mercs—Magic 8-ball
3 Mercs—Prof. Marvel
4 Mercs—Wizard of Oz

The deck's value as a fortune-telling tool. Obviously, any deck might be used to tell fortunes, so this is a rating of how well (or if) the deck is designed specifically for divination. The symbol is the astrological sign of Mercury.

Aesthetic
Rating

1 rose—DOA
2 roses—Velvet Elvis
3 roses—Warhol
4 roses—Picasso

The deck's aesthetic value, how well the deck's artwork is designed and particularly executed both as an expression of Tarot symbolic traditions, as well as an expression of the designer's individual vision. The symbol is the wild rose.

Buyer
Recommendation

1 star—trash, forget it
2 stars—barely worth it
3 stars—kinda worth it
4 stars—worth it
5 stars—best, gotta have it

The overall buyer recommendation—buy or not. This recommendation may or may not have anything directly to do with the sum of the other ratings. For example, a deck that rates low on everything but aesthetic value, but which has historical importance, such as Visconti-Sforza, may rate a high buyer recommendation. The symbol is the inverted 666 pentagram, symbol of Capitalism (and other stuff).

©2002 by j. karlin, all rights reserved